Humiliation as a Root of Social and Political Violence
In recent decades, many social philosophers and social psychologists have concluded that
humiliation is one of the most powerful drivers of collective and political violence.
Contrary to the common belief that violence is primarily the product of poverty or ideology, research suggests that the experience of
humiliation, degradation, and the trampling of human dignity
can generate an intensely explosive force.
1. Avishai Margalit’s Theory of the “Decent Society”
The Israeli philosopher Avishai Margalit, in his well‑known book The Decent Society, argues that:
A truly decent society is one whose institutions do not humiliate people.
He distinguishes between two concepts:
A just society
Focuses on the fair distribution of resources.
A decent society
Focuses on preserving human dignity and preventing humiliation.
According to Margalit, humiliation occurs when institutions:
- Portray individuals as worthless
- Render them invisible
- Or deny their human standing
Examples include:
- Systematic discrimination (think of quota systems)
- Degrading bureaucracy
- Racism
- Poverty accompanied by disrespect
He argues that institutional humiliation can produce deep and enduring social anger.
2. Humiliation and Collective Anger in Social Psychology
Research shows that humiliation produces emotions that differ from ordinary anger.
Characteristics of humiliation include:
- A combination of shame + anger
- A strong sense of severe injustice
- A desire to restore lost dignity
For this reason, reactions to humiliation often take the form of:
- Revenge
- Radicalization
- Symbolic or actual violence
3. The “Violence as a Response to Humiliation” Theory (James Gilligan)
American psychiatrist James Gilligan, who worked for many years with violent prisoners, reached an important conclusion:
In nearly all cases of severe violence, the primary underlying factor was the experience of humiliation and worthlessness.
He writes:
Violence is often an attempt to repair damaged self‑esteem.
In simple terms:
A person who feels that their human dignity has been crushed may resort to violence in an effort to restore it.
4. Collective Humiliation
When humiliation is experienced at the level of a group or a nation, it can become even more dangerous.
Historical examples often cited by analysts include:
- Germany after the Treaty of Versailles
- Ethnic humiliations during the Balkan wars
- Colonial humiliations in many societies
In such cases, humiliation becomes:
- A historical narrative
- A collective identity
- And a political motivation
5. Humiliation and Radicalization
Studies on extremism indicate that one of the key factors in recruiting individuals into extremist groups is:
A shared sense of humiliation and collective injustice.
Extremist groups typically do three things:
- Reinforce a narrative of historical humiliation
- Identify a specific enemy
- Promise the restoration of honor and dignity(One may think of extremist ethnic groups as examples.)
As a result, violence is justified as a means of restoring honor.
6. Humiliation in Everyday Relationships
Interestingly, the same mechanisms operate on a smaller scale:
- Humiliation within families
- Humiliation in the workplace
- Humiliation at school
Research shows that chronic humiliation can lead to:
- Aggression
- Bullying
- Revenge‑seeking behavior
7. Why Is Humiliation Psychologically So Dangerous?
Several key reasons:
1. Threat to Identity
Humiliation is not merely criticism; it is an attack on a person’s core sense of worth.
2. Public Nature
Humiliation often occurs in front of others.
3. Sense of Powerlessness
The humiliated individual feels unable to defend themselves.
This combination of emotions creates an explosive psychological state.
Conclusion
From the perspective of social psychology and political philosophy:
Humiliation is one of the strongest drivers of violence because it:
- Targets human dignity
- Creates a sense of injustice
- Combines anger and shame
- Activates the motivation to restore honor
For this reason, many thinkers argue that:
Preventing humiliation is one of the most essential conditions for social stability.
“Society and Mental Health”
This platform shares writings and materials related to psychology and psychiatry.
ID:
https://ble.ir/jamehvasalamtravan
Dr. Hamid Yousefi’s Website
Psychiatrist
بدون دیدگاه